7.9 C
Harrow on the Hill
Saturday, November 7, 2026
HomeCommunityAndy Burnham or Keir Starmer? Harrow residents deliver blunt verdict

Andy Burnham or Keir Starmer? Harrow residents deliver blunt verdict

Harrow residents have delivered a largely sceptical verdict on Andy Burnham as he prepares to replace Sir Keir Starmer as Prime Minister.

Harrow Online asked followers on Facebook and Instagram whether they believed Mr Burnham would do a better job in Downing Street than the outgoing Labour leader.

The question attracted hundreds of responses, with many readers saying they saw little difference between the two politicians. Others argued that Mr Burnham deserved an opportunity, while some called for the public to decide through a general election.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mr Burnham received 322 nominations from Labour MPs after nominations opened on Thursday, July 9, leaving him on course to take over the party leadership without a contest.

What makes people proud to be from Harrow? residents share their views

‘More fire in his belly’

Although most of the comments received by Harrow Online were negative or uncertain, some readers believed Mr Burnham could offer stronger leadership.

ADVERTISEMENT

Chetan Joshi said: “I think Andy Burnham would make a better statesman. I feel like he has more fire in his belly.”

Carol Carter gave a more direct response, saying: “You bet!”

Andy Wyatt said: “It couldn’t get any worse, so yes.”

ADVERTISEMENT

However, several readers said it was too early to judge.

Colin Heath commented: “I would be very surprised. Maybe different, but I have no confidence in him.”

David Englandskin said Mr Burnham’s appeal could depend heavily on where people live.

He said: “If you’re living in Manchester, you might think he’s the messiah. If you live elsewhere in the north, you might have hope in varying degrees.

“If you live in the south, you’re probably dreading it and expecting to be bled dry to pay for some wild ideas.

“Personally, I don’t think he has enough time in the three years left in this Parliament to get some changes through. We will wait and see.”

ADVERTISEMENT

‘Cut from the same cloth’

A repeated theme among the responses was that changing Labour leader would make little difference.

Gary New described Mr Burnham as “Starmer in jeans”, while Linda Billing said the two men were “two peas in a pod”.

Star Davis commented: “It doesn’t matter. They both work from the same sheet.”

Mary Fowler said: “Hardly, as they are cut from the same cloth.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Susan Smith added: “No, they’re on a par.”

Nada Haddad simply said: “They are all the same.”

Lidia Harding described the potential change as the “same circus, different clown”, while Spencer Attridge said it would be the “same thoughts, different person”.

Linda Ward Was Gould added: “They are as bad as each other. Let’s hope there is someone better.”

Varshaa Atara said: “All prime ministers would be the same. There is no difference — it is all talk.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Calls for a general election

A number of people questioned whether a new Prime Minister should take office without a nationwide vote.

David J Norman said: “No one deserves to be Prime Minister without a general election. Let the people decide who they want.”

Devendra Vora agreed, saying: “Only a general election would decide. Replacing prime ministers is pointless.”

Maureen Gibbon also said: “The public should vote.”

Pauline Freestone commented: “I’m not sure. We have no say in this. It’s going to happen whether we like it or not.”

ADVERTISEMENT

David Smith said voters often heard promises that were not eventually delivered.

He commented: “What they say to get into power and what actually gets done is another thing.”

Little confidence in politicians

Some readers said their concerns went beyond Mr Burnham and Sir Keir, arguing that they had lost confidence in politicians more generally.

Rosemary Spring said: “I can’t think of anyone I could trust to run our country.”

Bharat Shah commented: “The United Kingdom doesn’t have one competent person to become Prime Minister.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Liz Booth said: “There are no politicians around at the moment who are accomplished enough to be Prime Minister.”

Dave Moscrop added: “Neither is fit to govern this country.”

Elaine Hyatt Lochrie joked that Larry the Downing Street cat would be better, while Robert Moseley said: “Vote for Larry. He is a safe bet.”

Other tongue-in-cheek suggestions included Count Binface, Mickey Mouse, Clarkson’s dog and even a house brick.

Robert A Brown commented: “I, or my bin man, would make a better Prime Minister than either of them.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The responses represent comments voluntarily posted by Harrow Online followers and are not a scientific opinion poll.

NOW READ:

Harrow residents reveal where they’d take a first-time visitor – and the answers were very divided

Andy Burnham or Keir Starmer? Harrow residents deliver blunt verdict Harrow Online

Latest Posts